Many Christians who oppose homosexuality aren’t homophobic, but rather against unrepentant sin. However, there’s a double standard with that view, because masturbation, not forgiving, getting drunk and even overeating are also unrepentant sins, but they don’t seem to get people in trouble as often.
The issue of whether homosexuality is a sin isn’t Biblically very debatable: "Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God." 1 Corinthians 6:9-10
Many Christians who support homosexuality either regard Scripture as errant, have interesting alternative explanations of Scripture (http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_bibc1.htm) or try not to judge because they believe some people are created homosexual for a reason.
Based on my understanding of Scripture and following Jesus’ teachings in real life, I believe the early Christian orthodox teachings were against homosexuality. Jewish teachings were very strict in sexual relations and there’s no indication Jesus changed our understanding in any way in regards to homosexuality; whereas Jesus did change our understanding in regards to many other teachings about food, the Law, the State, the Greatest Commandment and established a new covenant with all people of the world, not only Israel.
However, the issue of ‘Is homosexuality a sin’ is not the main point. The main point is the purpose for sexuality altogether. Reproduction is the only meaningful purpose I can find for sexuality. Heterosexual sex and reproduction were inseparable in Biblical times, but not anymore. In our culture, sexuality is used for many other purposes, which all boil down to hedonism. Sexual hedonism is least destructive in marriage, because marriage contains love that usually overpowers hedonism. All your actions must be done out of love, not hedonism. If you’re not trying to reproduce, don’t have sexual relations. Be celibate.
These are difficult teachings to accept, especially in our culture, which is heavily influenced by Roman/Greek philosophy more than most realize. Based on these teachings, if I get married, I don’t want to reproduce because I want to adopt as many orphans as possible, hence I don’t plan on ever having sex even if I get married.
This type of ascetic teaching is practically impossible to follow unless your heart is fully behind it, or else you’ll resent the teaching. It’s worth following, because it allows you to love others to the utmost.
Some Christians feel fine pursuing pleasures (i.e. hedonism). They say, "If God didn’t want me to have sex, why would He make it so pleasurable?," which is akin to, "If God didn’t want Adam and Eve to eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, why did he make it so tempting?" Or "God created sex for us to enjoy." We should do all things out of love, not enjoyment. They can continue to say, "Sex is holy." However, sex is never inherently holy; love is holy. Sex is a lure for people to have children who would otherwise never have children; hence, sex is a lure to learning about sacrificial love, which helps us understand God better. Notice, sacrificial love from sex does not come from sex, but from raising children.
The logical outcome of this is we shouldn’t have sex for pleasure, period. This has actually been the Christian teachings for the greater part of Christian history. It doesn’t matter whether it’s heterosexual or homosexual. Many people who condemn homosexuals are hypocrites.
We shouldn’t judge others. The Bible says we should only judge believers or those in the Church. However, I feel no church is completely holy in its teachings, hence, I don’t judge anyone.
In conclusion, don’t focus on sexuality. God calls us to celibacy unless we’re reproducing, because this way, we can love others most purely.
Homosexuality vs. Loving asceticismThis entry was originally published at Interconnectedness by Mikhail (Misha) Lomize